Employers, this one’s for you.
Many candidates I speak to are passive. That is, they aren’t actively seeking a new position. I encourage them to keep an open mind and see what else is out there – if for no other reason than to do their due diligence to ensure they’re in a good spot. Most people recognize the value in this and will do so.
Oftentimes these conversations with recruiters pique a person’s interest enough that they want to proceed with an interview with the company to learn more, and so – the ball’s in motion. When that goes well, it’s on to the next round, and then the next, and before you know it – an offer’s on the table.
Suddenly that person who ‘wasn’t looking’ is telling their spouse, “I got a job offer today.”
So, what next?
I tell candidates, if after reviewing this offer, you’re not so pumped about it that you’d still consider taking a counteroffer if made by your employer, then just bow out now – for your own sake.
Giving notice and then taking the counter offer just creates a strange dynamic – people have told me they’ve been made to feel disloyal, or greedy. So, if you’re ready to walk away, go for it; if you’re not, just pretend you never got it and move on.
What are some common reasons people don’t accept the offer?
Bad reviews about the company. They’re excited about the process and like who they’ve met with – but they wait til the offer’s in hand to do their research. They go own a rabbit hole of Google and Glass Door reviews only to find feedback that’s not so great. The info may be accurate, it may not be – but ether way, the person’s spooked.
The raise isn’t commensurate with the ‘risk’. Most people aren’t going from comfortable into the unknown for a nominal pay bump. In my experience, most people seek ~10%+ in pay increase to justify taking the plunge into the unknown. (A few exceptions to this: Those who are downright miserable; those looking to gain a specific skill/experience they’re lacking, those seeking a more flexible/remote work environment.)
Guilt. Self-imposed or external. Either the person simply feels bad leaving their boss or favorite coworkers behind so they never accept the offer. Or, they confide in a colleague or give notice to their boss and receive a guilt trip – “I can’t believe you’d do this to us” or “You’ll leave us in such a pinch with the 1/1 renewals coming up”. It’s unfortunate but I’ve seen it more times than I can count.
Fear of change. Humans are inherently creatures of habit, wired to be averse to change. The “known” always feels safer. Things that fall under the FEAR umbrella include: “I’ll be the new guy, so will I be first to be canned if there are layoffs?”, “What if I can’t hit my new business goals and get fired?”, “What if I don’t like my new agents as much as my current ones?” People can really get inside their own heads when it comes to this stuff.
Gut feel. Something in their gut isn’t giving the warm and fuzzies about the new role. Maybe someone on the interview panel rubbed them the wrong way. Maybe there was talk about ‘one day’ pulling remote employees back in office. There’s just some nagging feeling things aren’t quite right that the person can’t shake.
Timing. Maybe the person was just diagnosed with a major illness. Maybe their parent just fell ill and will need a caretaker for a while. Maybe they just found out they’re pregnant. Or their spouse just lost their job. There are any number unforeseen events that can occur in the weeks that pass during the interview process that cause people to pump the breaks and say “I’m sorry, I need to pull out – one more change just isn’t the best thing for me right now”.
They weren’t committed/prepared to walk away in the first place. Sometimes the person was never going to leave in the first place. Maybe they were just wanting to be sure they were in a good spot. Maybe they wanted to exercise the interview muscles. Maybe they wanted to get an offer to force their employer into a raise. I’ve seen it all!
“Not all, but many of these things can be overcome by having candid conversations right up front and getting ahead of possible roadblocks. As the hiring team, be sure you’re getting feedback from the recruiter along the way, as well as candidate buy-in at each step in the process. Interviewing is the candidate’s first taste of what it would be like to work for you and your company – make sure it’s positive!”
